• Jeśli chcesz dodać swojej Alfie charakteru i jednocześnie zaznaczyć przynależność do naszej społeczności – to dobry moment, żeby je zamówić.

    Ramki Alfaholicy

    Szczegóły, zdjęcia oraz informacje o zamówieniu znajdziesz tutaj.

    Nie czekaj, bo jak zwykle schodzą szybko.

Collisions

Nice, these SUVs are. Such a big safe car :D
you can’t cheat physics, and another thing is that cars are as stable as sedans; when they get a shot and crash flying sideways, e.g., into a curb, they also often roll
 
I scanned the thread on Wykop, the owner is obviously dodgy, looks like he’s looking for fame.

The car is only slightly damaged, the structure is not compromised. Hard to call a rollover something you can describe as a tumble: D He says he hit his head on the steering wheel, then he would have had to drive without seat belts - airbags wouldn’t deploy by rule. He claimed he took a big hit, and he didn’t even get a cervical collar (or at least he didn’t mention it). He apparently broke the glass with his hand, and only scratched it, good luck :D

Airbags exist to deploy in case of a strong impact and high g-forces, not so that someone is comfortable when they’re being shoved.
 
@mareksz159 - eCall – the pan-European system for rapid emergency response. eCall is connected to the 'eSafety' initiative, which is part of the European Commission’s comprehensive strategy aimed at road safety and improving transport efficiency in Europe. eCall devices are mandatorily installed in all new passenger and light commercial vehicles up to 3.5 tons that received homologation after March 31, 2018.

The question is whether homologation is granted by the manufacturer when it releases a given model on the market or whether the moment of production of a specific unit matters? If we take the first position, then neither Giulia neither Stelvio need to have eCall.
 
to chyba by musiał bez pasów jechać - poduszki wtedy nie strzelą z zasady.

hmm Are you sure the airbag won’t deploy if you don’t fasten the seatbelt. I’m talking about the steering wheel airbag, of course. It seems to deploy regardless of the seatbelts. What about the other airbags like curtain or knee airbags?
 
Question: does the manufacturer obtain type approval at the moment they release a given model onto the market, or is the production moment of a given unit what matters? If we adopt the first position, then neither Giulia neither Stelvio need to have eCall.

Exactly as you write - they do not have to have it.
 
hmm Are you sure the airbag won’t deploy if you don’t fasten the seat belt. I’m talking about the steering wheel airbag, of course. It seems to deploy regardless of belts. What about the other airbags like curtain airbags or knee airbags?

well exactly from what I can see it’s hard to find a definitive answer. The system surely monitors seat belt fastening.

- - - Updated - - -

Question: does the manufacturer obtain type approval at the moment they release a given model onto the market, or is the production moment of a given unit what matters? If we adopt the first position, then neither Giulia neither Stelvio need to have eCall.

The vehicle model is homologated before being released onto the market, Stelvio it was already homologated earlier, so it does not necessarily have this system, but that doesn’t mean it doesn’t have it. one would have to ask.
 
hmm Are you sure the airbag won’t deploy if you don’t fasten the belts. I’m talking about the steering wheel airbag, of course. It seems to deploy regardless of belts. What about the other airbags like curtain or knee airbags?
Without fastened belts, especially the front airbag should not deploy.
This risks serious spinal injuries including fractures.

Sent from my Moto G (5S) Plus using Tapatalka
 
Without fastened belts, especially the front airbag should not deploy.
This risks serious spinal injuries including fractures.

Well, logic would suggest so, but on the other hand if you slam your face into the steering wheel or fly out through the windshield that’s also bad. Maybe a better airbag? I haven’t found any clear information that the airbag will not deploy if the appropriate belt isn’t fastened.
 
Well, logic would suggest so, but on the other hand if you slam your face into the steering wheel or fly out through the windshield that’s also bad. Maybe a better airbag? I haven’t found any clear information that the airbag will not deploy if the appropriate belt isn’t fastened.

Deployed airbag and unfastened belts is the worst scenario. Injuries are greater than if it hadn’t deployed. The airbag works correctly only in conjunction with seatbelts. Before a person reaches it, it must finish inflating. Otherwise an explosion of the charge and the shock wave will damage the body part (head, knees or side).
 
Well, logic would suggest so, but on the other hand if you slam your face into the steering wheel or fly out through the windshield that’s also bad. Maybe a better airbag? I haven’t found clear information that the airbag will not deploy if the appropriate belt isn’t fastened.

An airbag won’t protect you from being thrown through the front windshield. Besides, I’m not sure whether it’s better to crash into the steering wheel or fly into it and get a powerful blow from the airbag towards the opposite side.
 
Deployed airbag and unfastened belts is the worst scenario. Injuries are greater than if it hadn’t deployed. The airbag works correctly only in cooperation with seat belts. Before a person reaches it, it must finish inflating. Otherwise an explosion of the charge and the shock wave will damage the body part (head, knees or side).

Okay, as the instructions say, belt fastening is not a prerequisite for deploying the airbag.

"Front airbags (driver and passenger) protect front-seat occupants in frontal collisions of moderate-to-medium energy by separating the occupant from the steering wheel and the dashboard with an airbag.

The lack of deployment of airbags in other types of crashes (side, rear, rollover, etc.) does not indicate a malfunction of the system. Front airbags (driver and passenger) do not replace but complement the use of seat belts, which we always recommend fastening as prescribed by EU legislation and in most countries outside Europe. In a crash, a person not wearing a belt moves forward and may hit the airbag as it deploys. In such a situation the protection provided by the airbag is much lower. Front airbags may not deploy in the following cases: frontal collisions with easily deformable objects not involving the front surface of the car (e.g., hitting a fender against a guardrail); the car being driven into another vehicle or guard rail (e.g., into a truck or highway barriers). The lack of airbag deployment in these circumstances is due to airbags potentially providing no additional protection beyond seat belts and consequently their deployment is inappropriate. Lack of deployment in these cases does not indicate improper system function."

The above description explains the situation with Stelvio.

- - - Updated - - -

Besides, I’m not sure whether it’s better to bury your face in the steering wheel, or to hit the steering wheel and get a powerful blow from the airbag in the opposite direction.

From the manual it follows that you’ll still get hit by the airbag. I would probably rather get the airbag without seat belts than a punch to the face or chest from the steering wheel :)
 
From the manual it follows that you’ll still get hit by the airbag. I would probably rather get the airbag without seat belts than a punch to the face or chest from the steering wheel :)

In principle, without seat belts, in either case you’re done for :)
 
The airbag in the face is death on the spot.

Not exactly. I think if it were like that, car manufacturers would connect the seatbelt sensor to the airbag in fear of a bad reputation. A large portion of people, however, drive without seat belts.

per these studies http://www.upmc.com/media/NewsReleases/2004/Pages/seatbelts-spinal-injury.aspx

the differences compared to airbags and seat belts are as follows.

1.7 higher probability of injuries to the cervical spine and 2.4 spinal cord injuries - without belts and with airbag
1.3 higher probability of cervical spine injuries and 1.8 spinal cord injuries - without belts and without airbag
So it turns out the airbag is worse, especially for the spinal cord.
Fortunately I have never driven even a kilometer without buckling up. Even when I move the car I instinctively buckle up. I can’t imagine otherwise. I feel like I’m naked :D
 
From the manual it follows that you’ll still get hit by the airbag. I would probably rather get the airbag without seat belts than a punch to the face or chest from the steering wheel :)

Is it better to ram head-on into a wall, or into another car speeding towards you? :P The airbag opens in fractions of a second with a lot of force, so you get a double blast. The kinetic energy of your head adds up with the energy of the opening airbag. Only when the airbag is fully open does it cushion the impact; opening it prematurely does exactly the opposite :P

- - - Updated - - -

I can’t do otherwise. I feel naked :D

Exactly, that’s why I don’t understand people who drive without seat belts at all. Properly set, they don’t bother at all, and once you learn, driving without belts feels uncomfortable.
 
Last edited:
Better to hit head-on into a wall, or into another car speeding towards you? :P The airbag opens in fractions of a second with a lot of force, so you get a double blast. The kinetic energy of your head adds up with the energy of the opening airbag. Only when the airbag is fully opened does it cushion the impact; opening it would be just the opposite :P

Energies do not sum up. A collision with a wall and a head-on collision with another car differ only in the fact that the second car maybe absorbs some of the energy from our car, but the wall won’t do that, or will do so to a lesser extent. Although at higher speeds cars still "bounce" off each other, so the time to transfer energy is mega short. There was something like that once in Mythbusters.
 
Last edited:
Energies do not sum up. A collision with a wall and a head-on collision with another car differ only in the fact that the second car may absorb some portion of energy from our car, while the wall won’t do that, or will do so to a lesser extent. Although at higher speeds cars still "bounce" off each other, so the time to transfer energy is extremely short. There was something like that once in Mythbusters.

Yeah, true, oversimplified, not a very good example :P Here we have a wall rushing toward the head.
 
Today I got such a photo with a caption - too much power.
 

Attachments

  • Resized_20180804_185556_8573.jpg
    Resized_20180804_185556_8573.jpg
    301.2 KB · Views: 75
Amortyzatory
Back
Top