• Jeśli chcesz dodać swojej Alfie charakteru i jednocześnie zaznaczyć przynależność do naszej społeczności – to dobry moment, żeby je zamówić.

    Ramki Alfaholicy

    Szczegóły, zdjęcia oraz informacje o zamówieniu znajdziesz tutaj.

    Nie czekaj, bo jak zwykle schodzą szybko.

System start-stop

bami159

New
Joined
Aug 23, 2012
Messages
453
Car
Giulia
Hello, for a long time the system start stop doesn't work for me Giulia system start stop
 
Google according to the instructions in my signature. Very briefly, the presence of SS drains the battery quickly below 65% and that is the threshold for the system to operate. Then the so-called intelligent charging. Hence the problems with rapidly aging batteries, constantly undercharged, whose capacity drops and it gets worse. Below 50% the rear window heater doesn't work (despite the indicator being on) and below 35% the steering wheel and seat heaters don’t work. I recommend turning off SS automatically (from shop.stuff4car.com) and recharging the battery at least 2x a year (if you drive short trips then more often) - besides, in every car you can do the same with those who routinely drive several thousand kilometers per month, you need to top up the battery at least 2x a year.
 
Google according to the instructions in my signature. Very briefly, the presence of SS drains the battery below 65% and that is the threshold for the system to operate. Then the so-called intelligent charging. Hence the problems with rapidly aging batteries, permanently undercharged, whose capacity drops and it gets worse. Below 50% the rear window heater doesn't work (despite the indicator being on) and below 35% the steering wheel and seat heaters. I recommend turning off SS automatically (from shop.stuff4car.com) and charging the battery at least 2x a year (if you drive short segments then more often) - besides, in every car you can get by with those who monthly drive a few thousand km, the battery needs charging at least 2x a year.

Thanks for the exhaustive info, I agree with you that you need to recharge at least 2 times a year, even more (that's what I do, actually)…. though for me even after charging it doesn't work …. so either a weak charger I have from Lidl or I just don’t know what’s going on?
 
though for me even after charging it doesn’t work …. so either a weak charger I have from Lidl or I don’t know what’s going on?

A Lidl charger is junk. You might also have a bad battery. Buy an OBD interface, install the myGiulia app and check the IBS parameter.
 
Hmm, interesting why did my post (#2) disappear? it wasn’t removed by a moderator because I didn’t get notifications - what glitches do we have on the forum?
 
The battery charge assessment can be done very easily with a regular voltmeter — at least a few hours after the last drive or recharge, open the boot, then close the car with the key so the light goes out and systems go to sleep, wait a few minutes and then measure the voltage. Based on that voltage you can estimate SoC (state of charge). You can compare it with what IBS reports (the BCM parameter that doesn’t always read, but it’s also in the ECU and it’s always read there). It may be that IBS is dead (it happened).

However, other parameters (SoH, SoF, capacity) won’t work with the above methods, which may also be faulty — unfortunately computers do not provide those parameters, although IBS calculates them and computers use them.
SS logic depends on SoC but also according to official documents on SoH (or SoF I don’t remember after years of reading this). Additionally many other problems/errors can disable SS — for example very low external temperature (for example I’ll give only that because we don’t have such now, I think -27°C is a threshold, but the list is probably 20 or 30 different parameters). With an OBD interface you can check which reason was first considered by the computer (I don’t remember if this parameter is in the ECU or BCM, but in one of them).

The battery is probably for reconditioning — there’s no magic — every battery after a few years of being kept undercharged has a less dense electrolyte, hence lower capacity and worsened other parameters — in my wife’s Giulietta who exercises the battery with sporadic 1-5 km trips and in her spider V6 used sporadically, plus a faulty regulator on the alternator (not easy to fix — requires engine removal — no access), I simply do a proper recharge cycle 2x per year. Victron BlueSmart 12V/15A charger, I’ll set it in expert mode from my phone parameters. If the battery wasn’t brought to discharge then one recharge cycle, if it was (and it happens to my wife — she won’t notice that the battery is weak and suddenly only the phone says the car won’t start) then usually 2-3 reconditioning cycles starting lighter at 15.5V/3h, then 15.8V/4h and finally 16.1V for 5h recond, and after that a normal charging cycle at 14.7. I’ll push several tens of Ah into the battery, and when I connect the tester after the procedure my 6-year-old EFB in my wife’s Giulietta shows nice battery parameters continues to be.
Hmm, interesting why did my post (#2) disappear? it wasn’t removed by a moderator because I didn’t get notifications - what glitches do we have on the forum?
 
Last edited:
Since some time something has gone wrong with the views on mobile. Turn on the mobile view theme on your phone and you’ll see your post. In other themes you won’t see it. Also pay attention to the message number marker on the right and you’ll probably notice that there will be something like #1, #2 and then #4, and if that was your post there will be a missing #3.
I have at least that with many of mine, and sometimes I don’t even see posts from other users even though the markers indicate they existed. I have the same with yours which you probably don’t see either.

P.S. Victron BlueSmart 12V/15A - solid device :-). Some time ago I thought about buying it but it’s expensive and it seems it has problems charging small batteries (15Ah types in my wife’s Toyota).
But with a 3-amp Lidl charger and charging and reconciling is more like a failure.
 
AGM unfortunately. I bought a stabilized power supply with regulation 1-24V and 1-20A and built-in displays for settings for maybe $20 from a Chinese vendor - finally solved the problem. The supply even isn’t warm when I pull 14.40@9A. I don’t believe in any automatics. But you need to know what you’re doing with something like this...
 
okay, but if you have a 15Ah in that Toyota, then recharge with a limit of 1.5A for AGM - that’s what all sources say. I recharge AGM in Giulietta at 14.7V as well (a few times a year I have to recharge, because of too many different experiments, retrofits, trying new products, testing new versions/additional features/fixes etc).
 
cool, only if you have 15Ah in that Toyota, charge with a limit of 1.5A to the AGM - that’s what all sources say. I charge AGM in the Giulietta at 14.7V for that (a few times a year I have to charge, because of too many different experiments, retrofits, testing new products, testing subsequent versions/additional features/patches, etc).

Exactly like that I do! In general, as a rule I don’t exceed 10% for safety in anything.
When I’m dealing with audio or radar experiences I’m constantly on a charger because I would kill the battery in an hour or two by tugging current to the bass or turning the car on/off all the time. And now I’ve got an idea for a front camera, so back to experiments :-).
 
Hi

Is it possible that the battery drops below 65% (SS off) after about a week of short drives from full charging?
Every day 2 short drives of several minutes (I work from home, drop the kids to school, to the store and home, and then pick them up), maybe with one longer one, is that a sign that something is wrong?
Julka sits in a heated garage.

I know the question is very general and 'it depends', but could it be that big a degradation of the battery?
The multimeter showed 12.7V after the systems went to sleep.

EDIT: My bad, about 12 days from charging.
 
Last edited:
From "full charge" means from what value of IBS? I think it shouldn’t drop by more than 5%, at least for me when I charge to 85% (it takes long to pull above 95) it also takes long to drop below 80. Of course as you said 'it depends' what those runs look like.
 
Hi

Is it possible that the battery drops below 65% (SS off) after about a week of short drives from full charging?
Every day 2 short drives of several minutes (I work from home, drop the kids to school, store and home, and then pick up), maybe with one longer, is that a sign that something is not right?
Julka sits in a heated garage.

I know the question is very general and 'it depends', but could it be that big a degradation of the battery?
The meter showed 12.7V after sleep mode of systems.

EDIT: My bad, about 12 days from charging.
so these several dozen kilometers each time split into turning the car off at the school, then at the store, then at home, and again in the afternoon the same.
hard to say exactly. do you have a GPS tracker? or a camera in standby/image detection mode - they pull quite a bit (over many days - e.g., my previous Viofo A119S ate about 2.5Ah per day, i.e. about 30% of a perfect battery with 100% capacity in those 12 days).
Another issue is central unit updates, especially this TBM junk/alfa connect - in older versions they could discharge the battery overnight (I think they hung up and pumped at full power). Where do you park? Also consider TBM/alfa connect - after all, it communicates with the network all the time and consumes stuff constantly.
 
From "full charge" means from what value IBS? I think it shouldn’t drop by more than 5%, at least for me when I charge to 85% (takes long to pull above 95) it also takes long to drop below 80. Of course as you said "it depends" what those runs look like.

I still don’t have an ELM, so I don’t know :/ But it seems around 14V, right?
Soon I have a longer trip, but after returning I’ll recharge to max again and monitor more closely.

so these several dozen kilometers each time split into turning the car off at the school, then at the store, then at home, and again in the afternoon the same.
hard to say exactly. do you have a GPS tracker? or a camera in standby/image-detection mode - they pull quite a bit (in the span of many days - e.g., my previous Viofo A119S ate about 2.5Ah per day, i.e. about 30% of ideal battery capacity in those 12 days).
Another thing are firmware updates of the ECUs, especially that TBM junk/alfa connect - in older versions they could discharge the battery at night (they probably hung and pumped to full power). Where do you park? Also consider TBM/alfa connect - finally it communicates with the network all the time and eats stuff all the time.

There are a few lights along the road (3) and there SS would switch on, so there were a few more shut-offs. I have a camera without a motion park feature and that’s it with non-standard extras.
I park in the garage of the house.

So the conclusion would be that something is too fast after all :/
 
There are a few lights along the road (3) and there SS would switch on, so there were a few more shut-offs. I have a camera without parking mode and that’s it with non-standard extras.
I park in the garage of the house.

So the conclusion would be that something is too fast after all :/
wait, now you say SS was turning on, but in the original post you wrote "(SS off)". decide then.

if SS was on you have normal behavior. SS activates under certain conditions, but if the SoC of the battery is at least 65%. a few days of driving short trips, even with a new and 100% charged battery, at intersections where SS turned off the engine and you’re around 65% and you oscillate, over time the battery loses capacity because it’s always so charged, it starts to be less and it more quickly drops, then often you’re below 50% then rear window heating doesn’t work and the battery loses capacity again. many have gone through this.

SS works for a few percent of drivers, those who drive long trips so they can recharge and build some reserve (though even with smart charging you can’t build much more than 80%), and then somewhere they drive into the city and a few times the engine turns off and it isn’t such a problem.

people like you (and me), and unfortunately 95+% of drivers don’t have a chance to rebuild energy consumption while parked when mostly short segments are driven.

S&S is nonsense that was imposed by manufacturers to artificially lower CO2 emissions on paper and hence lower charges.
Similarly smart charging, which barely charges above 75% and nothing (only when braking) above 85%.

Hence there is an S&S deactivator in my shop, and soon IBS/battery tester/faker so you can also better recharge the battery e.g. heading out on a longer trip (to 95% not 80%) and build a reserve, slow aging of the battery, etc.
 
wait, now you say SS turned on, but in the original post you wrote "(SS off)". decide then.

if SS was on you have normal behavior. SS starts under certain conditions, but if the SoC of the battery is at least 65%. a few days of driving short trips, even with a new and 100% charged battery, to intersections where SS turned off the engine and you have 65% and you orbit around it, over time the battery loses capacity because it’s always so charged, it starts to be less and it drops faster, then often you’re below 50% the rear window heating doesn’t work and the battery loses capacity again.

many have gone through this.

Perhaps we misunderstood each other, maybe I described it unclearly.
During these 12 days from charging the battery with a battery charger SS was working, i.e., it turned off the engine at traffic lights and it started working fairly quickly, even the oil didn’t start to heat.
But yesterday it stopped turning on, i.e., the engine runs constantly in exactly the same places where it used to shut off.
12 days to discharge the battery below 65%. I wonder if such rapid discharge is normal.

As for the sense of S&S - I agree: none. However I’m reluctant to make permanent modifications while it’s still under warranty.
 
With me charging continuously is up to exactly 79%. It jumps to 80 and then only during braking.
Generally if SS is off and if I charge to 90-95% I have a few weeks of driving without dropping below 80. Mostly short trips. Plus my battery is technically junk because I once killed it to 8V during some audio experiments. But it seems it didn’t hurt it much contrary to popular opinion.

Jo_gurt, you’re talking about charging to full but how do you know it’s full if you don’t have an elm. I guess the charger finishes a cycle and something lights up, but that doesn’t indicate any 'fullness'. What charger is that anyway?
 
Last edited:
yeah, and what do you expect. at the start the charging strategy is basically that above 75% you have little charging and above 85% only during braking. It’s another nonsense of today’s cars, just so in a artificial test for emissions (where they’ll deliver the car with a 100% charged battery), it comes out slightly less.

so while driving short distances using S&S (after all the music plays, the fan runs, lights, you start it - every stop is say 0.1-0.5% less charge additionally it goes down), in a few days you reach 75%. then you have full charging at least, but you still use SS so you still discharge. 12 days with SS and short trips, 65% sounds reasonable. then it doesn’t drop because SS isn’t turned off, but you drive 10 km, it charges you to 66% and SS turns the engine off again and back to 65%. Cars that drive like you or me, where everything is working and the battery is good, sit at about 65% charge +/- about 2%. When you turn off SS in such a car you’re probably at about 75-78% - here the charging starts to drop so you can’t charge more.

My deactivate device (shop.stuff4car.com), you install in 1 minute, you can switch it off, you can pull it out. I should just mention that some dealers regularly take it from me for customers and they install it.
 
Jo_gurt, you’re talking about charging to full but how do you know it’s full since you don’t have an elm. I suspect that the charger ends your cycle and something lights up, but that doesn’t indicate any “fullness”. What charger is that anyway?

Well I don’t know :) As much as my voltmeter shows.
The charger I have is exactly like this: https://www.lidl.pl/p/ultimate-speed-prostownik-ulgd-10-a1-12v-lub-24v/p100361587
I had an ELM but it disappeared in action, maybe it stayed in a sold car.
Is there something specially recommended for MyGiulia?

epsonix said:
My deactivate device (shop.stuff4car.com), you install in 1 minute, you can switch it off, you can pull it out. Just to mention, some dealers regularly take it from me for customers and they install it.

I have big doubts about taking apart plastics, because I have a talent for breaking things ;) But it really looks simple. Won’t it throw errors after disconnecting the panel?

Thanks guys for the replies, you’re raising the level of this forum!
 
Amortyzatory
Back
Top