• Jeśli chcesz dodać swojej Alfie charakteru i jednocześnie zaznaczyć przynależność do naszej społeczności – to dobry moment, żeby je zamówić.

    Ramki Alfaholicy

    Szczegóły, zdjęcia oraz informacje o zamówieniu znajdziesz tutaj.

    Nie czekaj, bo jak zwykle schodzą szybko.

Giulia vs 159

ADAMSKY

New
Joined
Feb 27, 2016
Messages
3
hi,
Could someone who has driven or at least had both AR versions, or especially a specialist from service in an authorized service center, compare both Alfas: 159 and Giulia (mainly I mean petrol: 159: 1.75 TBI 200HP and Giulia: 2.0T 200HP)

I have a dilemma what car to buy (assuming the same mileage, up to 100,000 km)

How do they differ, i.e.; in individual main subsystems, in what way is the 159 better/different? (engine, intake, exhaust, suspension, cabin noise insulation, etc)
Please provide a professional approach.

I motivate writing this topic by the fact that in various brands it happened that newer versions were worse than the previous ones; and also that I would like to have a clear picture of the AR development. Giulia Please provide a professional approach.

I motivate writing this topic by the fact that in various brands it happened that newer versions were worse than the previous ones; and also that I would like to have a clear picture of the AR development. [o stylistyce i walorach estetycznych chciałbym przemilczeć ze względu na subiektywizm tych cech]

Proponuję zacząć od pobieżnego chociaż zapoznania się z
 

and its structure, especially the topics. Start with this section, and the question you asked What differences do they have, i.e.; in individual main subsystems, in what way the 159 is better/different?


will seem to you - at least that’s how it seems to me - peculiar.

Do you realize that this is an extremely different design or that in Poland customers receive 2.0 petrol engines from last December?
If not - and this is not malice - proceed to reading topics. It will be the professional approach you expect from other forum users.

In the Giulia section


Nasze Belle What differences do they have, i.e.; in individual main subsystems, in what way the 159 is you can currently find 3 Giulie , two are 2.2 D and only one 2.0 petrol by a friend from Olsztyn near Częstochowa (in presenting his Alfa he shares his first impressions of dealing with this version). Do you realize that this is an extremely different constructionsThat’s what it’s about, that they are different ... but are they better in Giulia? And in what sense are they different/better?
I know the question may seem too technical, hence I’m directing it more to forum regulars from the ASO (or those who just know).
best regards
 
Last edited:
), and it basically determines the possible answers. Starting from what each person likes (or for some reason prefers), ending with why and for what reasons (in relation to these preferences) it is better.
Nevertheless, maybe in a while someone will attempt such an analysis.

Writing this topic motivates me because in various brands it happened that newer versions were worse than the previous ones; and also that I want to have a clear picture of AR development. Q4Between the 159 and Giulia there is a 10-year difference, that’s a gulf. For example, probably at least 300 kg difference in mass.
 
is rear-wheel drive. This is not only different handling but e.g. different engine layout (longitudinal) - that decides balance. There is no such heavy front weight.
Today's electronic systems are a cosmos compared to 10-12 years ago.
These are two different, incomparable cars.
The only things that can be compared are their beauty, which is constant ;)

There is certainly one fairly significant thing in favor of the 159, although having a budget sufficient for buying a Giulia, and considering what was written above about brands - I would take the newer car.
Alright, back to the 159’s advantage over the Giulia, a decade on the market has one main plus.
Many people drive the E9x 3-series, know them inside out, know how they behave after a given mileage, parts will be cheaper and more available.
However,
Giulia it’s a fresh car, on the forum there are only 2-3, we don’t know how this car behaves after longer operation.
 
: 1374 - 1524 kg [4643x1860x1426]
2.2Jtdm - 1374
159 2.4Jtdm - 1630
GiuliaAn important parameter is the wheelbase - it is 12 cm longer for the Giulia. This certainly affects driving feel and rear interior space. That’s about the pluses.

For me, buying a Giulia at this price is a luxury for the wealthier. For this money there are cars offering the same but with solutions that have been working for a long time, and AR has only now introduced them.
For 2-3 years car markets are moving away from sedans because they are relatively impractical but Italians have their own vision.
Moreover, no one in the world starts a car presentation from the top-spec version. Top versions are promised, promised, promised and when it’s hot, boom! and we sell. But again the Italian vision. Unless the Italians think that with one run of QV around the Nurburgring they’ll beat legends like Porsche, Audi S, BMW M. These are 'symbols' built over the years and you cannot simply 'beat' them - moreover AMG Merc is also quite late to popularize it and also fights for a share of the pie.

Also just look at how AR sales have been over the last few years, what model range, to know that
 
Last edited:
2.2Jtdm - 1374
159 2.4Jtdm - 1630
GiuliaAn important parameter is the wheelbase - it is 12 cm longer for the Giulia. This certainly affects driving feel and rear interior space. That’s about the pluses.

For me, buying a Giulia at this price is a luxury for the wealthier. For this money there are cars offering the same but with solutions that have been working for a long time, and AR has only now introduced them.
For 2-3 years car markets are moving away from sedans because they are relatively impractical but Italians have their own vision.
Moreover, no one in the world starts a car presentation from the top-spec version. Top versions are promised, promised, promised and when it’s hot, boom! and we sell. But again the Italian vision. Unless the Italians think that with one run of QV around the Nurburgring they’ll beat legends like Porsche, Audi S, BMW M. These are 'symbols' built over the years and you cannot simply 'beat' them - moreover AMG Merc is also quite late to popularize it and also fights for a share of the pie.

Also just look at how AR sales have been over the last few years, what model range, to know that

Giulia this is a niche car with interesting chassis, engines and bodywork resembling what already exists. If it had a silhouette as unique and winning as the 159, that would be an argument.

Unfortunately in my view
 
it will not beat the sales of the 159, which was already embarrassingly low.

And 159?
It’s an old construction car. The youngest is 5 years old. These cars probably cannot be compared or should not be compared.

PS
In one thread I quoted a sales statistic for several brands.
You have to consider that if you 'hit' 2 million BMW or Audi of the same series, the cost of servicing these cars after warranty ends is several times lower than for the Giulia, which everything it has is new and will appear in disproportionately smaller quantities. Giulia The fundamental problem between Giulia and 159 is the fact that between the start of Giulia production and the end of 159 more than 5 years passed!! so there is no typical replacement model with the old one by a newer version, so you cannot go to a showroom to buy nm decreasing 159 instead of GIulia with an appropriate price difference.
Therefore comparing service costs (not counting purchase price) of a new car with minimum 5 (almost 6) years old is nonsense. Giulia Here is my professional answer:
Take a brand-new 159, because I understand you’ve seen it somewhere and you can buy it:edziahaha:
 
Recently I had the opportunity to test-drive Giulia 2.2. Hard to say after 15 km what this car is like. I missed fast corners, so I can’t assess much how it handles in bends. My father has a 159 1.9 JTS in a fairly rich spec. However, between Giulia and 159 there is an incredible technological gap, i.e. passenger assist, rearview camera, "unbending" turn signals, very large side mirrors, thick front pillars (which makes driving harder). In my opinion there are few references to the predecessor, if one can call it that... The suspension nicely soaks up irregularities, similar to the 159. However in my opinion it’s a bit more comfortable than in the 159. It’s still springy, but not as hard as in the 159. I’m writing this chaotically and in the moment. Happy New Year!
 
hi,
Could someone who has driven or at least had both AR versions, or especially a specialist from service in an authorized service center, compare both Alfas: 159 and Giulia (mainly I mean petrol: 159: 1.75 TBI 200HP and Giulia: 2.0T 200HP)

I have a dilemma what car to buy (assuming the same mileage, up to 100,000 km)

How do they differ, i.e.; in individual main subsystems, in what way is the 159 better/different? (engine, intake, exhaust, suspension, cabin noise insulation, etc)
Please provide a professional approach.

I motivate writing this topic by the fact that in various brands it happened that newer versions were worse than the previous ones; and also that I would like to have a clear picture of the AR development. Giulia Please provide a professional approach.

I motivate writing this topic by the fact that in various brands it happened that newer versions were worse than the previous ones; and also that I would like to have a clear picture of the AR development. [o stylistyce i walorach estetycznych chciałbym przemilczeć ze względu na subiektywizm tych cech]

Proponuję zacząć od pobieżnego chociaż zapoznania się z
I disagree.
 
is getting more orders. I know many people who will be switching from the 3 Series and C-Class to the AR. At this price it is really very competitive in its class. BMW with similar equipment and engine costs about 20k more. Alfa for the first time has a good offer for companies, and that is where BMW built a position.
 
it will not beat the sales of the 159, which was already embarrassingly low.

And 159?
It’s an old construction car. The youngest is 5 years old. These cars probably cannot be compared or should not be compared.

PS
In one thread I quoted a sales statistic for several brands.
You have to consider that if you 'hit' 2 million BMW or Audi of the same series, the cost of servicing these cars after warranty ends is several times lower than for the Giulia, which everything it has is new and will appear in disproportionately smaller quantities. Giulia The fundamental problem between Giulia and 159 is the fact that between the start of Giulia production and the end of 159 more than 5 years passed!! so there is no typical replacement model with the old one by a newer version, so you cannot go to a showroom to buy nm decreasing 159 instead of GIulia with an appropriate price difference.
Therefore comparing service costs (not counting purchase price) of a new car with minimum 5 (almost 6) years old is nonsense. Giulia Here is my professional answer:
Take a brand-new 159, because I understand you’ve seen it somewhere and you can buy it:edziahaha:

But what is there to compare. The 159, although still looks great, is an old model. Another thing is that the purchase costs of a used Giulia and a 159 not produced since 2011 will be drastically different. On the principle of 'I can spend up to 120k on a car but if the old one turns out better I’ll buy a 159 for 40k'. For me, absurd. Giulia has increasing orders. I know a lot of people who will switch from the 3 and C-classes to AR. At this price it is really very competitive in its class. BMW with similar equipment and engine costs around 20k more. Alfa, for the first time, has a good offer for companies, and that’s exactly where BMW built its position.
 
But what is there to compare. The 159, although it still looks great, is already an old model. Another thing is that the purchase costs of a used Giulietta and a 159 not produced since 2011 will be drastically different. On the principle of 'I can spend on a car 120k but if it turns out to be older I’ll buy a 159 for 40k'. To me, absurd.
 
But what is there to compare. The 159, although still looks great, is an old model. Another thing is that the purchase costs of a used Giulia and a 159 not produced since 2011 will be drastically different. On the principle of 'I can spend up to 120k on a car but if the old one turns out better I’ll buy a 159 for 40k'. For me, absurd. Giulia has increasing orders. I know a lot of people who will switch from the 3 and C-classes to AR. At this price it is really very competitive in its class. BMW with similar equipment and engine costs around 20k more. Alfa, for the first time, has a good offer for companies, and that’s exactly where BMW built its position.
I don’t deny that this isn’t true. However, for the company the customer who returns is what matters. Those, excuse the term, 'jumpers' will not build sales.
There’s no point speculating - add the thread to watch and see in a year how much of that sales really was.

I think you probably confused BMW with Skoda, KIA or Hyundai.

BMW and Audi are companies that have a model in every segment, even such absurd models as the BMW 2 Active Tourer, which not only has front-wheel drive but also looks like a KIA Carens :)

One more interesting fact - the sales of the X1 with front-wheel drive rose precisely because of that front drive. Currently the car is a tool and, although for us it sounds weak, rear-wheel drive cars in civil segments do not have a place, though a curious experiment is the Twingo with rear-wheel drive and sales of almost 100 thousand units per year.

To avoid writing more about this topic in this thread, I will say that the AR brand is close to me, I would like it to stand on its own and be a competitor to other brands. I’m afraid that they chose the wrong path :(
 
I don’t deny that this isn’t true. However, for the company the customer who returns is what matters. Those, excuse the term, 'jumpers' will not build sales.
There’s no point speculating - add the thread to watch and see in a year how much of that sales really was.

I think you probably confused BMW with Skoda, KIA or Hyundai.

BMW and Audi are companies that have a model in every segment, even such absurd models as the BMW 2 Active Tourer, which not only has front-wheel drive but also looks like a KIA Carens :)

One more interesting fact - the sales of the X1 with front-wheel drive rose precisely because of that front drive. Currently the car is a tool and, although for us it sounds weak, rear-wheel drive cars in civil segments do not have a place, though a curious experiment is the Twingo with rear-wheel drive and sales of almost 100 thousand units per year.

To avoid writing more about this topic in this thread, I will say that the AR brand is close to me, I would like it to stand on its own and be a competitor to other brands. I’m afraid that they chose the wrong path :(

Something doesn’t add up here, and since when is X1 FWD? confused Przecież to RWD/AWD :eek:
 
Something doesn’t add up here, and since when is X1 FWD? confused Przecież to RWD/AWD :eek:

From the current version - that’s called SDrive ;)
The first version was on the E91 platform. Now it’s a new platform - the same as the Mini Countryman.
And that is exactly the strength of the brand and good marketing - they don’t advertise it at all, hardly anyone knows, and 99% of people don’t see the difference and probably think it has rear-wheel drive. Again they went in response to market demand. And probably again it will pay off. And no one accuses them of moving away from their ideals.
 
Alright, I’ll say it - there is one "-" for the Giulietta compared to the 159 (since we’re talking sedans) - Giulia has a smaller boot (although as we know factory data say otherwise).
 
I think you probably confused BMW with Skoda, KIA or Hyundai.

Management, middle and upper level, owners usually choose BMW. Regular employees won’t get a premium company car (unless The Wolf of Wall Street is a buyer;)).
Alfa targets this market. Prices will probably rise to match the competition, but that will only benefit quality. It was the same with Ducati when they made the Multistrada and now they present new models every season.
 
Amortyzatory
Back
Top