This isn’t demagoguery but realities backed by knowledge from the field of mechanics. Read about how some engine components (main bearings, connecting rod) take a beating when driving at low revs with full load. I’ll skip the fuel consumption with such inefficient engine use. Show me a petrol engine of similar size with 4 cylinders having constant and maximum torque from 1500...?! Even in 8-cylinder units it would be a problem.
Yes, a bit of demagoguery, because both you and the previous posters cite extreme cases. Although perhaps I started by writing that “nothing happens.” Something does happen, but not too much. The key word above is “of similar size,” because this might simply be too small a engine to set the bottom end properly. I don’t know how it is with those 160/170 hp 1.4 TSI, perhaps similarly. I had an 1.8 TSI 160 hp and the bottom end was much better. And the new BMW engine for the current 20i versions has 270 Nm from 1200 to 5000, but that is two liters and maybe a bit unfair to compare, because it’s a different league. Regarding the bearing and crankshaft durability, without being an expert I joyfully assume the designers planned these elements to bear the maximum available stock torque. Recently I read that someone’s crankshaft “reared its head through the sump,” which concerned a specifically modified engine. Somehow there isn’t a mass problem with shafts and bearings, unlike e.g. turbos, DPFs, dual-mass flywheels, and clutches? Indeed, accelerating at full boost from 1000 RPM is a not-so-smart idea, but actively using this range during normal driving isn’t necessarily. For example, again BMW, this time 328i, probably around 250 hp, when driving calmly drops revs to about 1300, where it already has maximum torque, I think around 320, don’t remember. This is how petrol engines are made nowadays, so maybe don’t tell me about grandfathers, diesels, or whatever, because technology moves forward. At least that’s what I think. Well.
- - - Updated - - -
This isn’t demagoguery. After a spin in a Ferrari you’d also say it’s useless, because below 2k nothing happens? The fact that the MA isn’t particularly impressive is another matter...
Ferrari is useless, because it would stall on the garage incline.
