• Jeśli chcesz dodać swojej Alfie charakteru i jednocześnie zaznaczyć przynależność do naszej społeczności – to dobry moment, żeby je zamówić.

    Ramki Alfaholicy

    Szczegóły, zdjęcia oraz informacje o zamówieniu znajdziesz tutaj.

    Nie czekaj, bo jak zwykle schodzą szybko.

Chiptuning.

epsonix

Quadrifoglio Verde
Joined
Oct 8, 2011
Messages
11,312
Car
Ghibli'20 GS, Giulia'18 Q4, Tonale'23 MHEV, Spider'99 V6
Please in this topic paste your dynamometer charts and share your experiences with chip tuning.



This is probably the closest topic in the Giulietta forum section to post a chart before/after a chip, so I’ll also brag about my modification here. Braking done in N mode, tuning on RON98:
181400-chiptuning_-chip.jpg
 

Attachments

  • Chip.jpg
    Chip.jpg
    132.4 KB · Views: 1,029
Last edited by a moderator:
A big difference compared to stock :D, maybe a silly question, but if the tuning was done on 98, do you also have to drive on 98 :)
 
The tuning was done with the caution that we leave a safety margin - Cinek was supposed to not push it as hard as possible but make a solid jump, but with a bit more than the standard allowance (to sleep more easily).

for it to stay like that (i.e. the margin) you have to drive on RON98 - however for my wife’s car the mileage is like 5000 km a year, so +10% to fuel price is a small difference in annual maintenance costs.

I’ll just add that N and D had identically set ignition maps and turbo in stock - the difference in feel was only due to the throttle response settings! After the mod the maps are new but the same for N and D, while the turbo is set more for D - and you can really feel it - now the change from N to D really changes the car’s behavior in the range say 2-4k revs, then it’s the same (pity you couldn’t detune to D - traction control went into emergency mode and turned off D because the rear wheels wouldn’t spin)
 
Post the full chart if you have it. How much was it stock?
 
Post the full chart if you have it. How much was it stock?

After all, there is a full chart with lines before and after. Originally on a full tank of RON98 (but maps were factory on RON95 so it didn’t matter and could have slightly lowered performance with non-optimized maps) it came out about 129HP and 224Nm. A 2-year-old car with 10k km mileage.
 
Last edited:
Then I’ll add mine :) I had 95 in the tank, the tuner said after filling with 98 the gain could be even bigger + about 5-10hp and + about 10-15Nm. Is that true? I don’t know :)
attachment.php
 

Attachments

  • 12049622_711163375685222_6084395395368455827_n.jpg
    12049622_711163375685222_6084395395368455827_n.jpg
    110.3 KB · Views: 1,507
Then I’ll add mine :) I had 95 in the tank, the tuner said after filling with 98 the gain could be even bigger + about 5-10hp and + about 10-15Nm. Is that true? I don’t know :)
From my modest knowledge, after just filling with 98 you can have slightly worse performance than on 95. However 98 should give a bigger field for ignition map modifications, you can modify it more before knocking occurs. As far as I remember the tuning difference for 98 was supposed to be in the top of the rev range, so logically speaking it should be only about max power. Cinek told me that indeed you can achieve those 5-10HP more. I don’t recall any statement about the increase in torque after tuning to 98 versus tuning to 95, but I’m not an expert :)

BTW, I see you didn’t keep the stock before the mod - I think you should have at least 10HP more before. According to the manual 1.4MA should have 170HP at 5500 rpm, yours max is around 5100 and lower than it should be (and usually it’s higher by 5-10HP when everything’s tip-top with car and fuel). Are you sure you don’t have some minor malfunction? Or maybe the fuel is poor? I would not tune before the engine runs properly. Unless the dyno was uncalibrated and results are skewed? Sorry for ruining the mood, but it’s out of concern/just in case, I think it’s better to clarify the matter than fix the car later. Maybe ask in the Tuning department, or here, someone more knowledgeable than me and with more experience can comment on your chart.

- - - Updated - - -

A pretty nice result :).
Thanks, it now drives much nicer, the D mode is very pleasing. Cinek also encouraged changing the turbo to a bigger IHI (from Fiat Bravo Sport I think), but even so I managed to persuade my wife (it's her car) to at least go for a program mod - she said it’s fine as it is and it would mess up the car :) Now she says the car drives nicer, uphill she doesn’t have to downshift to 2. The car is driven in N, so she doesn’t benefit from the increased boost and torque (the steering is heavy in D). The task for Cinek was for the N map to be gentler for the wife, and the D map stronger for me.
 
Last edited:
Please in this topic paste your dynamometer charts and share your experiences with chip tuning.
 
From my modest knowledge, after just filling with 98 you can have slightly worse performance than on 95. However 98 should give a bigger field for ignition map modifications, you can modify it more before knocking occurs. As far as I remember, the tuning difference for 98 was supposed to be in the top of the rev range, so logically speaking it should be only about max power. Cinek told me that indeed you can achieve those 5-10HP more. I don’t recall any statement about the increase in torque after tuning to 98 versus tuning to 95, but I’m not an expert :)

BTW, I see you didn’t keep stock before the mod - I think you should have at least 10HP more before. According to the manual 1.4MA should have 170HP at 5500 rpm, yours max is around 5100 and lower than it should be (and usually higher by 5-10HP when everything’s tip-top with the car and fuel). Are you sure you don’t have some minor malfunction? Or maybe the fuel is poor? I would not tune before the engine runs properly. Unless the dyno is uncalibrated and results skewed? Sorry for spoiling the mood, but it’s out of concern/just in case, I think it’s better to clarify the matter than repair the car later. Maybe ask something in the Tuning department, or here, someone with more knowledge than me and more experience can comment on your chart.

I have no experience, I only rely on information from the tuner. Regarding the torque/power curve it may be due to TCT having a slightly different curve :) I have no problems with the car and from what I learned, different ‘factory-tuned’ cars arrive, sometimes better, sometimes worse. Thanks for the concern :)

If someone wiser than me in these matters would like to share, that would be great, I’m happy to read :)
 
It has already been in another thread, but once more. Maybe someone will want to compare.
181733-chiptuning_-hamownia.jpg
 

Attachments

  • hamownia.jpg
    hamownia.jpg
    70.3 KB · Views: 391
Could it be that the 1.4 MA doesn’t hold the stock 170 HP? In the 1.4TB 120 HP (Alfas and a few Bravos whose charts I’ve looked at) there’s always some bonus of about 5 HP, and in mine it was almost 10 HP. I had the same in the 159 1.9JTDm 16V - 160 HP instead of 150 and over 10 Nm more than stock (the car was then 7.5 years old, 110k km). A ton of others alfa,Fiats etc., always had something extra, unless there was a problem with something. Maybe it’s TTtM after all?
 
eee it isn’t that bad, though I don’t know how it looks for others :) in my stock it came out 178 HP, measured on load. I have the prints somewhere if someone wants; I’d have to just scan them, I probably won’t upload here because the topic is about mods and I’m stock for now :)
 
Roman, don’t you have holes in the intake?
 
I definitely have something, that’s why I’m trying everything and took it to the dyno.
And is this visible on this chart?
 
Could it be that the 1.4 MA doesn’t hold the stock 170 HP? In the 1.4TB 120 HP (Alfas and a few Bravos whose charts I’ve looked at) there’s always some bonus of about 5 HP, and in mine it was almost 10 HP. I had the same in the 159 1.9JTDm 16V - 160 HP instead of 150 and over 10 Nm more than stock (the car was then 7.5 years old, 110k km). A ton of others alfa,Fiats etc., always had something extra, unless there was a problem with something. Maybe TTtM after all?

I wouldn’t want to disrupt your peace, but if all your cars have 5-10 HP over stock, and all were measured on the same dyno, the first suspicion should fall on the dyno that overreads. Unfortunately, overreading dynos is a common practice, because everyone profits from it and is happy.

The second option is that you’re very lucky and you should play the Lotto - and the 4C would end up in your garage. :)

Now, seriously - measurements on dynos carry a significant error. This comes from the fact that for measurement accuracy, the mass of the rotating part (the car) is important. Flywheels, tires, discs, drivetrain components. In 99% of cases you blindly assume 60 kg, but of course this is a value pulled from the air. This value matters when converting the measured power to wheels to the engine power. The smaller the rotating mass on the car side (e.g., 40 kg instead of 60 kg), the greater the (apparent) engine power relative to wheel power.
 
I wouldn’t want to disrupt your peace, but if all your cars have 5-10 HP over stock, and all were measured on the same dyno, the first suspicion should fall on the dyno that overreads. Unfortunately, overreading dynos is a common practice, because everyone profits from it and is happy.

The second option is that you’re very lucky and you should play the Lotto - and the 4C would end up in your garage. :)

Now, seriously - measurements on dynos carry a significant error. This comes from the fact that for measurement accuracy, the mass of the rotating part (the car) is important. Flywheels, tires, discs, drivetrain components. In 99% of cases you blindly assume 60 kg, but of course this is a value pulled from the air. This value matters when converting the measured power at the wheels (assuming the measurement is reliable) to engine power. The smaller the rotating mass on the car side (e.g., 40 kg instead of 60 kg), the greater the (apparent) engine power relative to wheel power.

I dyno’d only two of my cars, I did it at Cinek’s, who, as far as I know, takes care of all timely dyno calibrations, sensor spacing, has a reputation as a forum specialist, has a good/new Maha load dyno, etc. You’d have to ask him for details, but from what I know he makes sure everything is done properly.

The rest of the charts I’ve seen are mainly from Cinek (Cinsoft’s Facebook), while dynoing other cars, though I also searched the net and saw from many other dynos. Healthy cars usually have a small bonus. Cars that don’t hold stock usually have some bigger or smaller problem - there were cases exactly from Cinsoft’s profile, where such a car after the first dyno was sent for repairs, and after return the stock was finally as in the book and you could do mods.

What drew my attention in previous charts (mostly in the one from fellow buczo) is that max power not only didn’t reach the book value, but the power curve drops from much lower RPMs. To this second problem, potential dyno calibration errors or entering more or less correct rotating masses would not affect it, agree with me? Power should still rise to the book 5500 rpm for MA. For me it was a bit suspicious and that’s why I pointed it out to my colleague. At colleague Roman35 it’s closer to stock in terms of max power point - 5450 came out, though the power still isn’t like in the book (but maybe there were some errors you mentioned). In my Julka TB, book 5200 rpm max power and 129 hp (book 120).

PS. I don’t play the lottery, honestly I wouldn’t want to "get rich" that way.
 
Last edited:
At the request of @Roman35 I’m posting scans of the stock measurements on the road dyno, both normal and dynamic.
The data seems real - here is my real acceleration test done probably about a year ago https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4pf6QgN3s8I . I wonder if there’s any sense in chip tuning - acceleration would probably have to drop below 7s :)


attachment.php

attachment.php
 
At the request of @Roman35 I’m posting scans of the stock measurements on the road dyno, normal and dynamic.
The data seems real - here is my real acceleration test done probably about a year ago https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4pf6QgN3s8I . I wonder if there’s any sense in chip tuning - acceleration would probably have to drop below 7s :)
....
Your max power is a bit before 5500, but you can still see (although the label hides it) that it holds roughly the same up to 5800 rpm and then drops. For some people it isn’t as good at high revs.

Regarding the sense of a mod on MA. 170 HP isn’t a small amount for a Giulietta; with 120 HP it’s much more justified. It depends on what everyone wants; for one person 100 HP would be too much, for another 240 in a QV wouldn’t be enough.

From what I think from our meet in the summer you have 16" wheels in your Julka, so probably on narrow tires 195/55R16 or 205/55R16. In that situation after a mod I would go for wider footwear - at least 225/45R17 - but then you’re facing additional costs of rims/tires and a bit higher fuel consumption. If anything, this should be taken into account.
 
Amortyzatory
Back
Top