• Jeśli chcesz dodać swojej Alfie charakteru i jednocześnie zaznaczyć przynależność do naszej społeczności – to dobry moment, żeby je zamówić.

    Ramki Alfaholicy

    Szczegóły, zdjęcia oraz informacje o zamówieniu znajdziesz tutaj.

    Nie czekaj, bo jak zwykle schodzą szybko.

Damaged BCM

hayo

New
Joined
Jan 24, 2024
Messages
4
Car
Alfa Romeo Giulia Veloce 2.0T 280KM MY20
Hi everyone. I have a few questions for Giulii owners or for people who know about electrical or electronics.

A month ago my 2020-built car went haywire at night and turned on the low beams, which could not be turned off except by disconnecting the battery. Moreover, the indicators and hazard lights stopped working. The diagnosis is a damaged BCM, which has already been replaced and everything is fine (I think). The cause of BCM damage is unknown, although the diagnostician suggests that the battery may have been replaced incorrectly (the order of disconnecting and reconnecting cables). I bought a new AGM battery after a few problems with the Christmas tree (maybe parasitic drain?), starting, and lack of start-stop. The shop seller recommended a specific model and replaced it at purchase. This was about 2 months before the BCM failure.

1. Is it possible that the incorrect order of disconnecting and reconnecting the battery cables could have caused BCM damage? Could an incorrectly chosen battery also cause such a failure? If so, should it not happen immediately after replacing the battery, and not as in my case after 2 months?

2. About half a year ago some madman while driving with low beams bumped into my left mirror. Only the indicator cover cracked, the turn signal worked fine so I didn’t pay attention and postponed replacing it. I recently noticed that during a visit to the car wash water gets into the indicator in the mirror. Since there is some plate, wire, basically electronics there, I wonder if it’s possible that water caused some short circuit or other situation (sorry, I don’t know much about electricity) which could have damaged the BCM?

3. Yesterday after collecting the car post- BCM replacement I noticed that when locking it from the key or from the button on the handle, the brake warning light on the instrument cluster stays on longer than the cabin illumination (with the parking brake engaged). After about 10–15 seconds it goes out, but the LED on the parking brake button stays lit for several more minutes. I don’t know if it’s my heightened sensitivity after BCM problems and I only noticed it now, or if it’s a sign of more trouble. I’d be grateful if an Italian engineering-minded owner could tell me whether theirs behaves the same or differently.

4. Is a BCM damaged in this way repairable? If so, do you know anyone who does such miracles, what to pay attention to, and przede wszystkim whether it’s worth doing at all? Stelvio and to people who know about electricity or electronics.

A month ago my Giulia built in 2020 went crazy at night and turned on the low beams, which could not be turned off any other way than by disconnecting the battery. Additionally, the turn signals and hazard lights stopped working. The diagnosis is a damaged BCM, which has already been replaced and everything is fine (I think). The cause of BCM damage is unknown, although the diagnostician suggests that the battery may have been replaced incorrectly (order of disconnecting and reconnecting cables). I bought a new AGM battery after a few problems with the Christmas tree, starting, and lack of start-stop. The seller in the shop recommended a specific model and replaced it at purchase. This was about 2 months before the BCM failure.

1. Is it possible that an incorrect order of disconnecting and reconnecting the battery cables could have caused BCM damage? Could an incorrectly chosen battery also cause such a failure? If so, shouldn’t it happen right after the battery replacement, and not as in my case after 2 months?

2. About half a year ago some psycho while driving with low beams touched my left mirror. Only the indicator cover cracked, the indicator worked fine so I didn’t bother and postponed replacing it. I recently noticed that during a visit to the car wash water gets into the indicator in the mirror. Because there is some plate, wire, basically electronics, I wonder if it’s possible that water caused some short or other situation (sorry, I don’t know electricity) which could have caused BCM damage?

3. Yesterday after collecting the car after BCM replacement I noticed that when closing it with the key or the button on the handle, the emergency brake indicator on the dash stays lit longer than the cabin lighting (with the emergency brake engaged). After about 10-15 seconds it goes out, but the diode on the emergency brake button stays lit for several more minutes. I don’t know if this is my heightened sensitivity after BCM problems and I only noticed now, or if it’s a sign of more trouble. I’d be grateful if an Italian engineering-minded owner could write whether it’s the same for them or different.

4. Is a BCM damaged in this way repairable? If yes, do you know someone who does such miracles, what to pay attention to and above all whether it’s worth doing at all?
 
1. It is theoretically possible but in practice it shouldn’t. I always connect the positive first, then the negative, disconnect in reverse order.
What does badly chosen mean? You won’t physically fit a too big one, a too small one will drain faster, but it probably won’t damage anything.
2. It depends how some fool designed it. If done correctly it shouldn’t matter besides making some operation stupid, not damaging. But in practice things differ when you short something in electronics.
4. Everything can be tried, but without schematic diagrams it’s a hard job. Although often you can repair electronics visually by looking for suspicious places, success is about 50/50 in such efforts. Another question is how much time/money it will take.
 
For me the BCM damage was caused by flooding after heavy rain. Check if the carpet under the footwell under the front passenger footwell is wet. If it sat for a while it could dry. They replaced it under warranty. And they stated the flooding water was poured in and it’s ok. They added the immortal TTTM.
 
What is TTTM?
Not sure if always but since the second-to-last facelift in Stelvio the computer is exposed, like a sheet of foil against flooding, I think.
 
What is TTTM?
Not sure if always but since the second-to-last lift in Stelvio the computer is exposed, like a sheet of foil against flooding, I think.

That guy has it this way. For me in stelvio In 2017 there was a service campaign for this, they gave a mat over the computer and sealed the joints of the bullbar under the hood with mastic.
 
Question whether if colleague has 2020 whether he already has this protection - factory or after the recall.
Maybe it was flooded by misfortune and that’s the cause.
 
I have a prod date of 09/2017 and the 'mat' was already there. The car did not have a service campaign for its installation
 
Thanks for the comments.

The problem of wet carpets obviously exists for me. It started last year in the summer after heavy use of air conditioning. A few times when the carpet was wet I checked the BCM and it was dry. I feared that if water didn’t flow directly under the carpet, condensation could cause damage. But nothing, always dry. Same thing happened a month ago. I checked BCM, wiring, connectors and the entire compartment. No moisture, corrosion, or water traces. The carpet was dry. There’s no way anything could evaporate. It never rained anything except the air conditioning situation. As for protection, I don’t have a tarp, only a plastic cover screwed in. I doubt water seeping through the carpet could get there. For this reason I ruled out flooding.

@Igor15799 At the ASO they told me that a wet carpet happened because water got in at the car wash. But I already know that condensation drips from the AC. Somewhere I read that some channel gets clogged with grime and that’s why it drips, but apparently it’s hard to reach to clean. You can’t count on the ASO, and I don’t have time or space to deal with it myself. Need to find someone who can handle it.

@netzmark By 'badly chosen battery' I mean badly chosen battery. So I don’t know. I assumed that like a sweater or shoes, a battery can be chosen badly :-)

For now I’m replacing the indicator in the mirror and probably just hoping nothing else goes wrong. Just in case I can cut a tarp to fit...
 
Thank you for the comments.

The problem of wet floor mats is of course present for me. It started last year in the summer after heavy use of the air conditioning. Several times when the mat was wet I checked the BCM and it was dry. I was afraid that if water didn’t get in directly by running under the mat, condensation could cause damage. But nothing, always dry. I did the same a month ago. I checked the BCM, wiring, plugs and the entire cavity. No moisture, corrosion, water traces. The mat was dry. There is no way anything could have evaporated yet. It never poured anything except the air conditioning situation. As for protection, I don’t have a plastic liner, only a plastic cover screwed down with screws. I doubt water seeping through the mat could get in there. For that reason I rule out flooding.

@Igor15799 At the ASC/official service they told me that water got in on the wet mat during washing. But I already know that condensate drips from the climate. I read somewhere that a channel gets clogged with filth and that’s why it drips, but apparently it’s hard to reach to clean. You can’t count on the ASC, and I don’t have time or space to deal with it myself. I need to find someone who can handle it.

@netzmark By wrongly chosen battery I mean a wrongly chosen battery. So I don’t know either. I assumed that, like sweaters or shoes, you can also pick a battery wrong :-)

For now I’m replacing the turn signal in the mirror and I guess I have to hope nothing else goes wrong. Just in case I can cut plastic sheeting to fit...

Water does not soak into the upholstery but pours down the bulkhead where you unscrew the flap. Wet carpet/upholstery is only a consequence of that. The plastic sheet is located above the computer, you can see it after removing the flap. Wife has Giulietta from the factory, 2017 model and there is no liner, mine has one. veloce from the Polish dealer, 2017 year and there is no liner, mine has one stelvio after the incident there is one.
 
By wrongly chosen battery I mean a wrongly chosen battery. So I don’t know either. I assumed that, just like a sweater or shoes, you can choose a battery wrongly :-).
It can cause starting issues or other problems that affect us when readings from IBS drop, but not BCM failures. So forget this problem likely. And what exactly did the guy put in for you? Check, AGM but probably also around 90Ah if removed - so if that's the case you’re surely okay with that.

Plastic cover for the computer comes with everyone, the liner is extra. If you don’t have it then you probably don’t have the seal that the guy above mentioned - think about adding it, it won’t hurt to have it.
 
For me, after downpours or car washes it was always dry. Both the carpet and the computer, cables, flap, etc. Only during heavy use of the AC in the summer did drips come from near the glove box and the central tunnel onto the mat. I know it dripped because my wife complained that cold water dripped on her feet. Since the cooling season ended, everything on the passenger side was dry. On the day of the failure as well. But the truth is also that I don’t check it after every downpour or visit to the car wash. Maybe an incident happened and you had to wait longer for the effects.

By the way, could someone with MY2020 confirm whether they have that liner from the start or had it added during a service campaign? I bought the car new and if there was such a campaign for my year, either the ASC didn’t handle it or I have to raise the issue, or this problem doesn’t occur here.
 
I’m not really following your statement :)

You mentioned BCM but you’re looking again for a replacement?
BCM after flooding is only moderately repairable. If not much, you can wash it. Then some people take a used unit and re-solder the processor (I don’t like this method). BCM is "hard" to disassemble.

There is also an option of replacement with coding on a used unit - and that is the most sensible. If anything, I’m here :)
 
@maly_777 I’m not looking for a replacement now, but since the cause of BCM damage is unknown, I assume the failure could repeat. I have this damaged BCM in the trunk and I’m simply wondering if it can be revived somehow. I don’t know much about it, so I’m asking. If not, there’s nothing left but to dispose of it.
 
Amortyzatory
Back
Top