• Jeśli chcesz dodać swojej Alfie charakteru i jednocześnie zaznaczyć przynależność do naszej społeczności – to dobry moment, żeby je zamówić.

    Ramki Alfaholicy

    Szczegóły, zdjęcia oraz informacje o zamówieniu znajdziesz tutaj.

    Nie czekaj, bo jak zwykle schodzą szybko.

Requesting opinions

A

alfa-beta

Guest
I bought an Alfa Romeo Giulietta in January 2011. When changing winter tires (on steel rims) to summer tires (on aluminium rims—not original Alfa rims) I noticed that all four brake discs in the part where the wheels are bolted are heavily corroded, as they were not protected against corrosion. I reported the defect to the service. Unfortunately it was not accepted by Fiat Poland (the warranty) due to the fact that such a defect is normal when buying a car with steel rims. The discs are painted in the case of buying a car with aluminium rims. After three months, when I discovered it, the discs look as if rust is consuming them for at least 10 years. I warn all potential buyers about this problem. I ask other users for information whether the discs on their cars are also rusted after such a short period of use. Or maybe, contrary to Fiat’s claims, they are painted, and in my car it’s just carelessness or an oversight during assembly.
 
With aluminium rims, the disc is painted in a gray color. No corrosion or trace.
 
Mate, disc corrosion is, first of all, not a defect :)
Normal reaction of steel with water, apparently you have the first car with ventilated discs.
But seriously, wash your car and leave it for 20-30 minutes, then take a look at the discs, you’ll see rust forming over them.

Tip for the future: with every tire/wheel change, simply run a wire brush over the discs and spray some WD on them and you’ll be OK,
of course I’m talking about the part of the disc that the wheel contacts.
 
Well, it doesn’t look too good, but rust on the discs is rather standard. Before they rust through, they’ll need replacement (assuming the car moves).
 
answer

Mate, disc corrosion is, first of all, not a defect :)
Normal reaction of steel with water, apparently you have the first car with ventilated brakes.
But seriously, wash your car and leave it for 20-30 minutes, then look at the discs,
you will see how they rust over.

For future reference, with every swap (tire/rim change) it’s enough to run a wire brush over the discs and spray some WD on them and it’ll be OK,
of course I’m talking about the part of the disc to which the wheel rim attaches.

I see you didn’t understand the topic. Rust is a secondary issue. The problem is that the manufacturer (or distributor) treats buyers of cars with steel rims differently - the discs aren’t painted, whereas with aluminium rims the discs are painted. That’s at least what the warranty says. I just want confirmation or denial from you. of these words.

---------- Post added at 16:08 ---------- Previous post was at 16:06 ----------

I see you didn’t understand the topic. Rust is a secondary issue. The problem is that the manufacturer (or distributor) treats buyers of cars with steel rims differently - the discs aren’t painted, whereas with aluminium rims the discs are painted. That’s at least what the warranty says. I just want confirmation or denial from you. of these words.​



Read more: http://www.forum.alfaholicy.org/mito_giulietta/51249-prosba_o_opinie.html#ixzz1NBUOp7Cb
 
...The problem is that the manufacturer (or distributor) treats buyers of cars with steel rims differently - the discs aren’t painted, and differently with aluminium rims - the discs are painted.....
Where do you see a different treatment, simply discs intended for mounting aluminium rims are painted, and for steel rims not.. And it isn’t a defect - I don’t know a car where the discs don’t rust
 
If they are painted, perhaps because, although I may be wrong, to hinder direct contact of two metals (alu+steel) and create a galvanic cell that consumes aluminium (this topic reminds me of something about CO installations). Or perhaps just for aesthetic reasons, so the different treatment of buyers of alloys is justified. But I still don’t believe such paint would last long given the temperatures during braking. If only such problems existed...
 
I see you didn’t understand the topic. Rust is a secondary issue. The problem is that the manufacturer (or distributor) treats buyers of cars with steel rims differently - the discs aren’t painted, and with aluminium rims the discs are painted. At least that’s what the warranty says. I just want confirmation or denial from you about these words.

---------- Post added at 16:08 ---------- Previous post was at 16:06 ----------

I see you didn’t understand the topic. Rust is a secondary issue. The problem is that the manufacturer (or distributor) treats buyers of cars with steel rims differently - the discs aren’t painted, and with aluminium rims the discs are painted. At least that’s what the warranty says. I just want confirmation or denial from you about these words.​



Read more: http://www.forum.alfaholicy.org/mito_giulietta/51249-prosba_o_opinie.html#ixzz1NBUOp7Cb

in the standard on FGA
if you have alu then for example the drums are painted, if not after a year they look like they’re 10 years old
in alu you can see more, so they are painted :)
in julia I also have non-original aluminium rims, but you don’t see rust - because you don’t see the discs, hubs, calipers
for calipers buy red Brembo covers, and paint the rest and you’re done
 
to hinder direct contact of two metals (alu+steel) and create a galvanic cell that consumes aluminium
at the moment of joining two metals (alloys) a galvanic cell may form, but only if the connection is very tight (this problem occurs e.g. during welding of different materials). honestly I don’t know whether the wheel-disc connection would create such a cell. another thing: steel and aluminium alloys do not form a cell as strong as steel and copper alloys...
 
Dear Alfa enthusiasts, I am a proud owner of a car with disc brakes and I must admit honestly that I have never come across painted brake discs. They are made from a special high-carbon steel alloy that reacts very quickly with water, especially if it is water with salt (I confirm the opinions of my predecessors). Lubricating or painting friction elements is very dangerous, as it creates a coating over which the brake pads will slide. Only the brake calipers and perhaps parts adjacent to the rim can be painted, but that is not always the case. The brake disc, like seals, is a consumable part that is replaced every several tens of thousands of kilometers (depends on driving style) and during that period the original parts certainly will not rust under normal use.
 
Last edited:
Dude, this is not about the friction surface of the disc but about the mounting face (the contact surface) of the wheel rim.
 
Dude, this is not about the friction surface of the discs but about the mounting face of the rim.
Yes, I know. I tried to answer comprehensively. Perhaps the part about the friction surfaces was superfluous, but sometimes (when it comes to safety) it's better to say more than too little.
 
Last edited:
Honestly, I don't know exactly what materials brake discs are made from - probably high-carbon steel, and such always tend to corrode. There is no possibility of making high-carbon steel resistant to corrosion. The question is only whether it wears away fast enough that rust spots disappear (which I doubt).
 
Discs are cast from gray cast iron - they must rust and they rust even after leaving the car wash.
 
That the manufacturer (or distributor) treats buyers of cars with steel wheels differently - discs are not painted, and differently with aluminum wheels - discs are painted.
Exactly. Cars with aluminum wheels have painted discs (or non-working parts) or drums in black, with steel wheels they do not - At least this is how Fiat Auto Poland does it.
 
Amortyzatory
Back
Top