• Jeśli chcesz dodać swojej Alfie charakteru i jednocześnie zaznaczyć przynależność do naszej społeczności – to dobry moment, żeby je zamówić.

    Ramki Alfaholicy

    Szczegóły, zdjęcia oraz informacje o zamówieniu znajdziesz tutaj.

    Nie czekaj, bo jak zwykle schodzą szybko.

Gear shift indicator

D

darek3972

Guest
With great curiosity I observe the operation of the gear shift indicator in my Julka. I drive a Citroën at the same time with a device like this, so I have a sort of comparative scale. While in Cytryna everything looks okay, and the indicator signals changing gear at the proper speed and engine RPM, Julka astonishes me every day, and most of all when it indicates a gear change while the car is coasting in neutral :). Well, women are inscrutable. Is this just a peculiarity of my Julka?
 
I have the same, but not very often, though on the other hand I’m driving in N mode less and less, because I don’t like it. Another interesting thing with these arrows is that they tell you to shift up already around 1,500 RPM, which seems a bit too 'eco' for my sense of driving comfort and potential engine life. Although it’s true that when the load increases, the arrows suggest a reduction.
 
...and especially when it indicates a gear change while the car is coasting in neutral...?
Because when coasting in neutral the car shouldn’t roll - setting aside safety, keeping it in neutral consumes more fuel than driving with a gear engaged. Therefore the computer signals to engage a gear.
 
From my observations of fuel injection times (1.4 naturally aspirated) it turns out that it doesn’t matter - fuel consumption is similar whether in gear or in neutral (not counting the 2 l/100 on the computer). Only above 3,000 RPM the injection time = 0 ms. Setting safety aside, coasting is cheaper because the car continues to roll;).
 
In neutral, the engine consumes about 4 litres per hour; while engine braking the consumption is at the border of 2 litres.
 
Could it be that new Alfa engines have brought a revolution? All petrol engines with injection that I had in cars cut off the fuel completely when engine braking beyond some minimal revs.
 
All petrol engines with injection that I had in cars cut off fuel completely when engine braking beyond some minimal revs.

Well, either they don’t cut off, or the computer is cheating, because it always shows those two litres per hundred. I’m a bit surprised too, but I don’t really know how to verify it. Regarding the safety mentioned earlier in driving in gear, I don’t think that’s what these arrows are about, because at the RPM levels they suggest (e.g. between 1200 and 1500) in N mode, since in D there are no arrows, the car responds to pressing the accelerator with a big reserve (as well as the arrow suggesting a reduction lighting up).
 
Radzi, you’re so active in this thread, as if you’re already moving Julka along :) When are you finally buying????
 
In the official configurator it has been there for a long time - yet half the options are missing and you can't choose the 1.4 MA engine. Generally you can slam it against the back bumper ;).
 
With great curiosity I’m observing the operation of the shift indicator in my Giulietta. I’m driving at the same time a Citroën with the same device, so I have a comparative scale. While in the Citroën everything looks OK, and the indicator suggests changing gear at the proper speed and engine revs, my Giulietta astonishes me every day, especially when it indicates a gear change while the car is coasting in neutral :). Well, women are unpredictable. Is this just a peculiarity of my Giulietta?

with me it never indicated a change when I was coasting in neutral
 
The computer indicates it that way because probably that is the minimum value set in its software, they just didn’t think someone would drive so Eco. And besides, all that driving according to the indicators in N mode is, firstly, not cost-effective, secondly, terribly tiring. alfa I did a small test I drove the route to work and back first exactly according to the indications in N mode and the next day (same temperature) in D mode in my style but not too hard, yet faster than the previous day
Average consumption in N mode 5.8 liters and in D 5.5 liters
Driving according to those hints is torturing the car and when climbing any hill it causes even more fuel consumption
 
I did a small test I drove the route to work and back first exactly according to the indications in N mode and the next day (same temperature) in D mode in my style but not too hard, yet faster than the previous day

Average consumption in N mode 5.8 liters and in D 5.5 liters
Driving according to those hints is torturing the car and when climbing any hill it causes even more fuel consumption

I also have the impression that in D mode it uses slightly less fuel. Of course consumption depends on driving style, but with similar styles it seems to me that in D it uses less. Means my numbers are twice yours, but that’s probably how it should be. :cool:

Regarding that ascent, isn’t it that as engine load increases it tells you to downshift? It does for me. But when accelerating smoothly, the suggestion to shift to a higher gear comes at around 1400 rpm. Maybe it’s eco-friendly, but you’d need an automatic transmission for that.
 
All these hints about when to change gear are just... hints ;) As you say, the car can’t know for sure if soon we’ll be driving uphill or if in 200 meters we’ll stop at a red light. So you should drive mainly with your head and in your own way, and treat the car’s tips as optional ;)
 
Amortyzatory
Back
Top