As far as the compromise between power and fuel is concerned, I think you couldn't have chosen better - of course this is just my opinion and it may differ from other users. I am a happy or unhappy user of such an engine (my doubts come from the excessive reliability issues of my car, though in every case they stemmed from my neglect or the ineptitude of our “mechanics”). To not be wordy, I’ll give an example of a diagnosis and repair performed by a “good recommended mechanic.” During a long trip the car suddenly loses power, stalls, and when trying to restart it, the dipstick shows oil so dirty it smeared absolutely everything under the hood. Of course a tow truck because the mechanic supposedly has one; verification of fault and diagnosis—head gasket. I know about mechanics and this diagnosis didn’t sit well with me. I suggested looking for another cause but nothing came to mind besides a check of the turbo and purge line, which the guy immediately dismissed with his theories. On my urging, the mechanic called a friend who works at an authorized Alfa service and heard “99% head gasket, 1% hole in the piston and there’s no other option.” To my dismay, the mechanic removed the cylinder head and surely he was surprised when he saw an unharmed gasket and, as he said, the pistons and cylinders showed little wear from vehicle usage

Unfortunately I had to leave that place and continue the trip in a borrowed car, leaving the mechanic with the problem. At home I had tons of parts for the car and asked my brother to bring them all to him because they might be useful (cylinder head, turbo, EGR, oil pump) and to have them handy just in case. After a few days he calls me, that he assembled everything on a new gasket because sometimes the gasket doesn’t show signs of damage. His astonishment doubled when he started the engine and it was splattered with oil, including the head

After a few more days he calls me and proudly informs me that the car runs like new. I went, loaded the entrusted parts into the car (examining them closely), and we test drove the car, and finally we discussed the price for the work: 2000 PLN. The guy included oils, filters, head gasket and other gaskets plus his labor. He was surprised to be told that I wouldn’t pay for learning and misdiagnoses. I asked for a receipt in which I suggested listing 400 PLN as the service “turbocharger replacement in 159 2.4.” Well, my dear, while packing the entrusted parts I noticed that I was packing the wrong turbine, which told me what the real cause of the oil throwing was. The mechanic issued the receipt, took the money and said the rest would be pursued by court. I did not wait for the lawsuit to come, and the evidence lies and waits for the case

with a twisted shaft

The cause of the failure was a twisted shaft in the turbocharger, which caused exhaust gases at high pressure to reach the crankcase through the turbo lubrication system

I know the guy worked hard but if he had at least been honest I would have given him more, but when asked what ailed the engine he answered that sometimes things get dismantled, aired, cleaned and start working. It worked—but on me

Returning to the question I still think this engine is great. My minimal fuel consumption on a long trip at night was 5.9 L, but I didn’t exceed 120 km/h, and the average was about 9 L. Regards and I encourage you.
- - - Updated - - -
I’ll add that now, since I have to go to the mechanic (due to lack of time), I go with a diagnosis, scope of work and the price for the service

And as for the 159 with the 3.2 engine I’ll say this—great impressions, the car is overall great but the fuel consumption is about the same as a 5.7 Corvette

The Jaguar 4.2 drank less

And I’ll add that I know what I’m saying
